Cookie Cutters
cookie cutters — pre-owned
Browse 29,120 cookie cutters — pre-owned on eBay — listings updated every few minutes. All items are pre-owned and sold by eBay sellers directly.
Antique Hand Soldered Fish Cookie Cutter
Old shows it needs a bath or ten about 4.25" long all dimensions are approximate
Martha Stewart Copper Large Star Light Star Bright Cookie Cutter
Perfect for baking enthusiasts and collectors alike, this cookie cutter is a unique addition to any baking supplies collection.
You save $22.75
Michael Bonne Copper Cookie Cutter Moon HARD TO FIND
Rare and HTF moon copper cookie cutter made by Michael Bonne. I never used it but listing it as used due its age. Cookie cutter is in good shape , it does have copper patina, spots and light oxidation along welding lines. Please see photos as they are part of the description. let me know if you have any questions.
Martha Stewart By Mail Copper Cookie Cutter BIG HEART 8 x 6 with Handle Vintage
This item, proudly made in the United States by Martha Stewart, adds a touch of charm and nostalgia to your kitchen baking experience.
You save $24.50
1996 LONGABERGER COOKIE MOLD ANGEL SERIES "JOY" MINT & BOXED RECIPES
The 1996 Longaberger Cookie Mold from the Angel Series features a "Joy" design, perfect for holiday baking. Made of ceramic and oven-safe, this vintage stone cookie mold is a collectible piece that adds a touch of Christmas spirit to your kitchen. With a festive Christmas pattern and angel theme, this United States-made mold comes boxed with recipes, making it a delightful addition to any baking enthusiast's collection.
Vintage Copper Color Aluminum Cookie Cutters Holiday Lot of 8
All are clean and in excellent condition.
Martha Stewart Martha By Mail ABC Alphabet 26 Copper Cookie Cutters 3”
Cookie cutters are in very good preowned condition. Look like new. Come in original packaging with insert. Please see all photos for accurate measurements and condition description. I am happy to answer any questions. Fast, secure shipping.
Vintage Lot of 13 Aluminum Cookie Cutters with Green Wood & Metal Handles
12 green handles + 1 red handle = 13 cookie cutters.
VTG "MICHAEL BONNE MADE IT" MELTING SNOWMAN large Copper Cookie Cutter Christmas
Vintage MELTING SNOWMAN 6 1/2" x 5" Large copper cookie cutter designed by coppersmith Michael Bonne...and perfect for ALL OCCASION baking...especially winter and Christmas. This wonderful cookie cutter is sure to add a unique touch to your cookie-making process. Handmade in the United States, this cutter is stamped "MICHAEL BONNE MADE IT" on the handle. I am the original owner and purchased it many years ago from Michael and Teresa Bonne when they had a shop on eBay. It is in very good unused condition...only displayed. I have listed several other Michael Bonne copper cookie cutters. This comes from a smoke free home and will be sent by USPS Ground Advantage Shipping with tracking and insurance. Auctions can be combined to save on shipping.
Lot (6) Antique Primitive Heart Cookie Cutters Soldered Tin Folk Art (1) Fries
Lot of (6) Primitive Heart Shaped Folk Art Tin Cookie / Biscuit Cutters. Included are the following.
4 Copper Cookie Cutters - Camping - Feather, S’more, Wolf, and Camp Fire
Solid copper cookie cutters made by The Fussy Pup Includes: s’more, camp fire, feather, and wolf See images for details; make an offer for if you don’t like the price!
Copper Cookie Cutters - Dog Treat Makers Lot - Bones and a Paw - Made in the USA
Solid copper cookie cutters made by The Fussy Pup Includes: 5 various bones and a paw See images for details; make an offer for if you don’t like the price!
VTG DANCING ELF large Copper Cookie Cutter MICHAEL BONNE MADE IT Christmas 6.5"
Vintage DANCING ELF 6 1/2" Large copper cookie cutter designed by coppersmith Michael Bonne...and perfect for ALL OCCASION baking. This wonderful cookie cutter is sure to add a unique touch to your cookie-making process. Handmade in the United States, this cutter is stamped "MICHAEL BONNE MADE IT" on the handle. I am the original owner and purchased it many years ago from Michael and Teresa Bonne when they had a shop on eBay. It is in very good unused condition...only displayed. I have listed a similar ELF Michael Bonne copper cookie cutter and several others. This comes from a smoke free home and will be sent by USPS Ground Advantage Shipping with tracking and insurance. Auctions can be combined to save on shipping.
SIGNED Antique H.L. HERBST Large Flatback Tin Cookie Cutter DEER
An antique flatback tin cookie cutter signed H.L. HERBST of a deer. I couldn't find this maker online, making this a rare cookie cutter. Maker stamped at the inside center. I also have listed a signed H.L. HERBST pig tin cookie cutter.
Vintage Mirro Aluminum Halloween Witch on Broom Stick & Cat Cookie Cutter Pair
Vintage Mirro Aluminum Halloween Witch on Broom Stick & Cat Cookie Cutter Pair. Please view pictures CAREFULLY as they are part of the description. Smoke-free home. Clean. Approx 5".
Rare Martha By Mail 5pc Set Copper Cats Cookie Cutters Vintage Collection
Rare Martha By Mail 5pc Set Copper Cats Cookie Cutters Vintage Collection. Condition is Used. Shipped with USPS Ground Advantage.
Vintage Lot Of 38 Cookie Cutters Plastic & Metal Holiday Birthday Wilton & More
This vintage lot of 38 cookie cutters includes a variety of plastic and metal designs perfect for holiday and birthday baking. Featuring a Christmas theme, the cookie cutters come in a standard size with a colorful multicolor finish. Brands like Wilton and more are represented in this collection, making it a unique addition to any baking enthusiast's repertoire. The nostalgic charm and variety of shapes in this lot of cookie cutters is sure to inspire creative baking projects for all occasions. Mixed lot: some say Wilton but I’m not sure the other brands. Storage unit find, will definitely need to be cleaned. We welcome all questions prior to bidding. Thank you!
Antique Copper Cookie Cutters Pair | Hand-Formed c. 1890–1920 Baking Tools
These would have been used in a Victorian or Edwardian kitchen for cutting pastry, biscuits, or bread dough, likely hung on a wall or kept in a wooden drawer alongside other essential baking tools. By the 1930s, copper was largely replaced by tin-plated steel and aluminum, making surviving examples like these increasingly scarce.
VTG Plastic Cookie Cutters Lot Of 69 Tupperware, Betty Crocker, Wilton, Etc
This lot of 69 vintage plastic cookie cutters includes brands like Betty Crocker, Tupperware, Wilton, and more. Made from durable plastic, these cookie cutters are perfect for collecting or for adding a nostalgic touch to your baking accoutrements. With a variety of fun shapes and designs, these cookie cutters are sure to inspire endless creative baking projects. 1303 Please see photos for details
Lot of 9 Vintage Tupperware Cookie Cutters – Seasonal Many Holidays
Gingerbread Boy.
Vintage Metal Cookie Cutters Playing Cards Club Spade Heart Diamond & Star Moon
Each cutter is designed in the shape of a heart, spade, club, diamond, star, or moon, adding variety and fun to your baking projects.
20 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Cutters Red Green Wood Handles Christmas Santa LOT
Hearts / Donut / Clover / Circle / Diamond.
VTG LOT (21)***Cookie Biscuit Cutters Metal Aluminum Tin Holiday Animal Baking
The VTG LOT (21)***Cookie Biscuit Cutters Metal Aluminum Tin is a set of 21 cookie cutters in various shapes, made of aluminum and tin. Perfect for baking, these vintage cookie cutters add a nostalgic touch to your kitchen and are ideal for creating festive and unique cookies and biscuits.
Lot Of 27 Metal Cookie Cutters Christmas Santa Horse Tree Easter Vintage More
It includes multiple characters such as a Christmas tree, gingerbread man, Christmas tree, bunny, heart, moon, lion, horse, diamond, spade and many more as shown. All in good shape.
Vintage 1989 Pillsbury Doughboy White Plastic Cookie Cutter 4 1/2"
The Vintage 1989 Pillsbury Doughboy White Plastic Cookie Cutter is a small, white cookie cutter made of plastic, standing at 4 1/2" tall. This vintage collectible from 1989 features the iconic Pillsbury Doughboy logo and is a unique addition to any kitchen or home decor. The California Prop 65 Warning indicates that this product may contain chemicals known to cause cancer, making it a unique and nostalgic piece for collectors of vintage baking accessories. This item has some light wear.
Lot of 20 Vintage Plastic Cookie Cutters HRM Circus Animals Dog Cat Goat Holiday
Lot of 20 vintage adorable plastic cookie cutters Includes circus animals and HRM brand
Lot Of 17 Vintage Aluminum Cookie Biscuit Cutters With Handles Assorted Shapes
Original owner. See photos.
Martha By Mail Halloween Cookie Cutter Set Complete w Box & Booklets Rare
Martha Stewart collectors. Cookie Cutter Shapes Include. ✔ Halloween cookie cutters. Booklets included. ✔ Original presentation storage box. Clean overall presentation. Halloween baking. Halloween character shape.
Pink *Elephant* Aluminum Cookie Cutter w/ Wooden Handle / Knob
The cookie cutter is clean and in very good condition. It lays fairly flat and doesn't seem warped. It is bright and shiny with not a lot of scratches. See all 11 pictures for details.
4 Copper Cookie Cutters - Big Christmas Trees - Includes unique shapes
Solid copper cookie cutters made by The Fussy Pup Includes: a three trees shapes tested for our line but not added and a tall curved one that is especially spotted from water. See images for details; make an offer for if you don’t like the price!
2 Foose Sunbonnet Sue Cookie Cutters Classic Quilting Appliqué Pattern
2 Foose Sunbonnet Sue Cookie Cutters Classic Quilting Appliqué Pattern. 2” X 3 1/4”.
You save $2.40
Vintage Large Copper Pumpkin Thanksgiving Halloween Cookie Cutter 4.25 x 4.5"
4.25" x 4.50". I have a few other large copper cutters listed (apple, heart, crab and snowman, turkey and Christmas Pine Tree).
4 Copper Cookie Cutters - Animals - Hedgehog, Hippopotamus, Lemur, Bear
Solid copper cookie cutters made by The Fussy Pup Includes: a hedgehog, hippo, lemur, and bear. See images for details; make an offer for if you don’t like the price!
Scholastic 1988 Clifford the Big Red Dog With Bone Cookie Cutter
Scholastic 1988 red plastic cookie cutter set of Clifford the Big Red Dog and his bone. Clifford the Big Red Dog. Clifford and Bone Set.
Martha by Mail Copper Cookie Cutters Barnyard Hen & Hatching Bunny FAST SHIPPING
Sold together. They could use a deep clean/polish but other than that there’s nothing wrong with them. Sold as pictured. If you have any questions please feel free to contact me at any time.
Vintage Christmas HRM Cookie Cutters Set of 9 Hanging ornaments Red plastic 50s
Gold thread has been added to hang them or cut it off and use for cookies. The photos are of the actual item you will get.
You save $9.98
Vintage Wilton Copper Cookie Cutters -Heavy Gauge Rolled Edge -Christmas & Teddy
The Vintage Wilton Copper Cookie Cutters Lot of 10 are heavy gauge rolled edge cutters featuring Christmas and teddy bear designs. Made of solid copper, these cookie cutters are perfect for creating festive holiday treats. The size varies from 3" to 6", adding variety to your baking projects. With a whimsical Christmas theme, these vintage cookie cutters bring a touch of nostalgia to your kitchen decor and culinary creations.
17 Vintage Martha Stewart Noah’s Ark Copper Cookie Cutters
17 pre owned Martha Stewart copper cookie cutters from Noah’s Ark set. Polish if you wish.
X-Large Bunny Flat Back 8”T X 10” W Tin Cookie Cutter Handle Primitive Antique O
Cookie Cutter With Handle. Must Have For Any Retro Decor Or Cookie Cutter Collection. "BUNNY RABBIT”. Crudely Soldered Together Onto A Piece Of Tin. Very Good Antique Used Condition. Extra Large. Will Make A Great Gift!
You save $12.49
